Despite its eerie ambiance, there are not many myths concerning the cemetery, with the most prominent involving a serial killer who supposedly lives in the lighthouse and kills players at midnight, though there is no solid evidence to support this myth.
During the mission Blood Brothers, Niko is given the choice to kill either Derrick or Francis McReary. If Francis is killed, he is buried at the cemetery. There have been reports of his ghost in the cemetery.
In the popular YouTube "Silent Hell" machinima, the climax of the series features Luis Lopez being hunted by Pyramid Head at the lighthouse.